The MPLS WG Archive

[Rob Coltun <rcoltun@redback.com>]

We're starting to move into inappropriate territories. Can we move this thread
to the more appropriate dukeitoutsomewhereelse mailing list.

thanks,
---rob

>
>
> Yesterday, in response to Bryan,  it was 'hogwash' today its 'FUD'. This is
> not your usual dispassionate approach. Has something touched a raw nerve ?
>
> There's an unintentional, I'm sure, hilarity in your last paragraph. While
> Robert's
> probably going a little over the top with his "market concensus" (he was
> probably
> using George's definition) how about "widely adopted" ? Don't you think that's
> overstating the case just a wee bit ?
>
> pd
>
> Eric Rosen wrote:
>
> > When someone  asks a  question which is  of the  form "which vendor  has the
> > best product offering for some  particular purpose", you can't really expect
> > a technical discussion to follow, but you can expect a lot of FUD.
> >
> > This thread is of that sort.  All you can learn from it is that everyone has
> > their  own favorite  scheme,  and you  can  pretty much  guess which  scheme
> > someone will like by noting which company he works for.
> >
> > You know the thread has reached  the point of absurdity when people refer to
> > a scheme  which has been widely adopted  and assert that there  is a "market
> > consensus" against it.